Giving a Pet as a Holiday Gift: What to Know First

By Waggle Finder Admin
November 8, 2026 5 min read
Giving a Pet as a Holiday Gift: What to Know First

A puppy with a bow on Christmas morning is a classic picture. But a pet isn't a sweater you can return, and many people warn against giving animals as gifts at all.

The good news is that a pet can be a wonderful gift, as long as it's the right pet for the right person, and they've had a say. Here's what to think about first.

What the research says

For years, shelters advised against giving pets as gifts, worried that they'd be returned once the novelty wore off. In 2013, the ASPCA studied it. It surveyed 222 people who had been given a dog or cat in the previous 10 years:

  • About 86% still had the pet, or kept it for the rest of its life. That's the same rate as pets people got in other ways.
  • About 96% said getting the pet as a gift made them love it more, or made no difference.

After the study, the ASPCA changed its advice. It now says pets can make good gifts, for people who have shown they want one and can care for one.

So the problem isn't the gift. It's giving a pet to someone who didn't want it, or couldn't look after it.

Ask first, don't surprise

The surprise is the riskiest part. Before you give a pet, make sure the person:

  • Wants one now. Not just "someday", and not just because the puppy is cute.
  • Has the time. A dog needs walks, training and company every day, for 10 to 15 years or more. Cats need less time, but many live 15 years or more.
  • Is allowed one. Many leases and homeowners' associations limit pets, or charge a pet fee or deposit.
  • Isn't allergic, and neither is anyone they live with.
  • Has room in their budget (more on that below).
  • Wants this kind of pet. A border collie puppy and a calm senior cat are very different gifts. Our dog breed guide covers size, energy and how much care each breed needs.

Giving a pet to your kids? Then it's really a pet for you. Children can help with feeding, walks and play, but an adult needs to be ready to do the rest, every day, for years.

Let them choose

Even someone who really wants a pet will usually want to pick their own. Some gift ideas that keep the surprise but let them choose:

  • A card with a leash, collar or toy, and the promise of a trip to a shelter.
  • An offer to pay the adoption fee. Some shelters and rescues sell gift certificates.
  • A book about the breed or kind of pet they want.

Then go together, after the holidays, to find the right pet. Browse pets up for adoption near you from local shelters and rescues to get started.

Wait until after the holidays

The holidays aren't a great time to bring an animal home. There are guests, noise, travel, late nights and food on every surface. A new pet does best with a quiet house and a routine.

If you do get a pet over the holidays, give them a quiet room to retreat to, and keep holiday food out of reach. Our guide to Thanksgiving foods dogs and cats can and can't eat covers what's safe. If you're traveling, book their boarding or pet sitter early.

The real cost of a new pet

The adoption fee or price is the smallest part of the cost. Estimates for a dog or cat's first year commonly run from about $1,000 to well over $3,000, depending on size, health and where you live. In the first year, that includes:

Shelters often include vaccines, spaying or neutering, and a microchip in the adoption fee, which can make adopting cheaper than it first looks.

Watch out for holiday puppy scams

Puppy scams go up every holiday season. The Better Business Bureau says reports of pet scams rise from October through January. A scammer posts photos of a puppy for sale, takes a deposit, then keeps asking for more money, for shipping, insurance or a special crate, until the buyer gives up. There's never a puppy.

Warning signs:

  • They won't video call to show you the puppy, or let you visit.
  • The price is very low for the breed.
  • They want payment by wire, gift card, payment app or cryptocurrency, which you can't get back.
  • New fees keep appearing after you've paid.
  • They rush you, saying other buyers are waiting or the price is only for today.

Never pay for a pet you haven't seen in person or on a live video call. Paying by credit card gives you some protection if something goes wrong. Better yet, adopt from a shelter or rescue you can visit, or buy from a breeder who lets you meet the puppy and its mother.

The first weeks at home

Once your new pet is home:

  • Book a vet visit in the first week or two. Bring any records from the shelter or breeder. If you don't have a vet yet, find veterinarians near you.
  • Keep up with vaccines. Puppies and kittens need a series of shots. See our vaccine schedule for which ones, and when.
  • Get an ID tag and register the microchip with your contact details. A new pet doesn't know its way home yet.
  • Pet-proof your home. Put away cords, cleaning products, medicines and small things a puppy or kitten could swallow.
  • Start training early, with patience and treats. A dog trainer can help, especially with a puppy.

WaggleFinder's free pet care reminders can email you when your new pet's vaccinations, flea and tick treatment and vet visits are due.

Gifts for people who already have pets

If someone you know already has a pet, there are easier gifts to give:

Whatever you decide, a pet is a gift that lasts for years, so it's worth getting right. Happy holidays!